Managing debt effectively is crucial for financial stability. When looking to consolidate debt or finance a large purchase, two common options are personal loans and balance transfer credit cards. But which is better? The right choice depends on factors like interest rates, repayment terms, credit score, and financial goals.
In this guide, we’ll compare both options in detail, helping you determine which is best for your situation.
What Is a Balance Transfer Credit Card?
A balance transfer credit card allows you to move existing debt from one or more credit cards to a new card with a lower interest rate, often 0% for a promotional period. This can help you pay off your debt faster without accumulating additional interest—provided you clear the balance before the promotional period ends.
Pros of a Balance Transfer Credit Card
Interest-Free Period – Many balance transfer cards offer 0% interest for an initial period (e.g., 12–24 months), allowing you to repay debt without incurring extra charges.
Lower Costs (if used correctly) – If you pay off the full balance before the promotional period ends, you avoid high interest charges.
Flexible Repayments – You can make minimum payments while prioritising other financial obligations, though paying more reduces debt faster.
Cons of a Balance Transfer Credit Card
Balance Transfer Fee – Most providers charge a fee (typically 2%–4%) to move the debt.
Limited Interest-Free Period – Once the promotional period ends, interest rates can jump significantly, sometimes exceeding 20% APR.
Credit Score Requirements – To qualify for the best balance transfer deals, you need a good credit score.
Temptation to Spend More – Transferring balances to a new card may free up credit on old cards, increasing the risk of further borrowing.
What Is a Personal Loan?
A personal loan is a lump sum of money borrowed from a bank, credit union, or online lender, repaid in fixed monthly instalments over a set period. Personal loans can be used for debt consolidation, major purchases, or unexpected expenses.
Pros of a Personal Loan
Fixed Interest Rates – Unlike credit cards, personal loans usually have fixed interest rates, making budgeting easier.
Predictable Monthly Payments – Repayment terms are structured, ensuring steady progress in clearing debt.
Lower Long-Term Interest Costs – If you have a good credit score, you may secure a lower APR compared to standard credit card interest rates.
No Temptation to Reuse Credit – Unlike credit cards, once the loan is paid off, you don’t have a revolving credit line to reborrow from.
Cons of a Personal Loan
Interest Charges Apply Immediately – Unlike balance transfer cards, you start paying interest as soon as you take out the loan.
Potential Fees – Some lenders charge origination fees or early repayment penalties.
Credit Score Requirements – Better rates are offered to those with strong credit histories.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing
1. Interest Rate and Costs
Balance Transfer Cards: 0% APR during the promotional period, but high rates afterward.
Personal Loans: Fixed APR, usually lower than a credit card’s standard rate.
2. Repayment Period
Balance Transfer Cards: Short-term, typically 12–24 months before high interest applies.
Personal Loans: Longer repayment terms (1–7 years) with fixed instalments.
3. Loan Amount
Balance Transfer Cards: Suitable for smaller debts (£1,000–£10,000).
Personal Loans: Better for larger sums (£5,000–£25,000 or more).
4. Credit Score Impact
Balance Transfer Cards: Applying for multiple cards in a short time may lower your credit score.
Personal Loans: Fixed-term loans may improve your score if repaid on time.
5. Financial Discipline
If you’re confident you can clear debt quickly, a balance transfer credit card may work.
If you prefer structured payments and a longer repayment period, a personal loan may be better.
When to Choose a Balance Transfer Credit Card
A balance transfer credit card is best if:
You have existing credit card debt with high interest.
You qualify for a 0% APR promotional period.
You can repay the balance within the interest-free period.
You are disciplined enough to avoid additional spending.
Example Scenario
Emma has £4,000 in credit card debt with a 22% APR. She qualifies for a balance transfer card with a 0% APR for 18 months and a 3% transfer fee (£120). By paying £223 per month, she can clear the debt before interest kicks in.
When to Choose a Personal Loan
A personal loan is the better option if:
You need to borrow a larger amount.
You prefer fixed monthly repayments.
You want a longer repayment period.
You don’t qualify for a balance transfer card.
Example Scenario
James needs £10,000 to consolidate multiple debts. He takes out a personal loan at 6% APR over three years, with fixed monthly payments of £304. He avoids high credit card interest and pays off the debt within a structured timeframe.
FAQs
1. Will a balance transfer card hurt my credit score?
Applying for new credit can cause a temporary dip in your score. However, successfully paying off your balance can improve your credit in the long run.
2. Can I use a personal loan to pay off credit cards?
Yes, many people use personal loans for debt consolidation to reduce interest rates and simplify repayments.
3. What happens if I don’t pay off my balance transfer card in time?
Once the 0% APR period ends, your remaining balance will be charged interest at the card’s standard rate, which can be much higher.
4. Can I get a balance transfer card if I have bad credit?
It’s unlikely. The best deals require a good to excellent credit score. If you have bad credit, a personal loan or credit builder loan might be a better option.
5. Can I transfer a loan to a balance transfer card?
No, balance transfer cards only allow the transfer of credit card debt, not personal loans.
Final Thoughts: Which Option Is Best for You?
The right choice depends on your financial circumstances:
If you can pay off debt quickly and qualify for a 0% APR offer, a balance transfer credit card is ideal.
If you need more time and structured repayments, a personal loan is a better long-term solution.
Before choosing, compare deals, calculate total repayment costs, and consider your financial discipline. Both options can be effective if used correctly—so pick the one that aligns with your goals.
Subscribe for more tips! Subscribe to our newsletter
Disclaimer: Smart With Money may receive compensation from affiliate links, advertisements, and partners featured on this site. This compensation does not influence our editorial content, reviews, or recommendations. Our opinions are our own, and we aim to provide accurate and objective financial information to help you make informed decisions.
Additionally, all content provided on SmartWithMoney.co.uk is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Please seek independent financial advice before making any financial decisions.