If you're looking to grow your money through investing, you've likely considered two of the most talked-about options: cryptocurrency trading and stock trading. Both offer the potential for returns, but they come with very different risks, strategies, and market behaviours — especially for UK-based investors navigating taxes, regulation, and volatility.
So, which one is better: crypto or stocks? The answer depends on your goals, experience, risk tolerance, and investment timeline.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the key differences between crypto and stock trading, compare their pros and cons, and help you decide which one aligns best with your personal finance strategy. Whether you're new to investing or expanding your portfolio, this side-by-side comparison is designed to give you clarity and confidence.
What Is Crypto Trading?
Crypto trading involves buying and selling digital currencies, such as Bitcoin (BTC), Ethereum (ETH), or Solana (SOL), with the aim of making a profit from price fluctuations. These assets are decentralised, meaning they're not controlled by any government or central bank, and they can be traded 24/7 on global cryptocurrency exchanges.
There are several types of crypto trading:
Spot trading: Buying and selling coins for immediate settlement.
Margin trading: Using leverage to trade larger positions.
Futures trading: Agreeing to buy or sell crypto at a future date for a set price.
Day trading or swing trading: Based on short-term price movements and technical indicators.
Crypto trading tends to be highly volatile, with large price swings occurring over short periods — which can mean both big gains and steep losses.
What Is Stock Trading?
Stock trading refers to buying and selling shares of publicly traded companies, such as Tesco, Barclays, or Apple. When you own a stock, you're buying a slice of that company — and your returns can come from both price appreciation and dividends.
You can invest in stocks via UK brokers like Hargreaves Lansdown, AJ Bell, or Freetrade, and trade on exchanges such as the London Stock Exchange (LSE) or New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
Types of stock trading include:
Buy and hold investing: Long-term investment in fundamentally strong companies
Active trading: Short-term buying and selling to profit from price swings
Dividend investing: Building income from companies that pay regular dividends
Unlike crypto, stock trading is limited to business hours on weekdays — usually 8am to 4.30pm in the UK for the LSE.
Key Differences Between Crypto and Stock Trading
1. Market Hours
Crypto: 24/7, including weekends and holidays
Stocks: Weekdays only, specific hours (varies by exchange)
Verdict: Crypto wins for flexibility, especially for those who prefer evenings or weekends.
2. Volatility and Risk
Crypto: Extremely volatile. Price swings of 10–30% in a day aren’t uncommon.
Stocks: Less volatile. Blue-chip stocks tend to be more stable.
Verdict: Stocks offer more predictability; crypto offers more potential reward — and more risk.
3. Liquidity
Crypto: High liquidity for major coins; altcoins may have low volume.
Stocks: High liquidity for large-cap stocks; smaller stocks can have wider spreads.
Verdict: Both markets are liquid, but crypto can be unreliable for smaller coins.
4. Regulation and Protection
Crypto: Lightly regulated in the UK. Not protected by the FSCS (Financial Services Compensation Scheme).
Stocks: Heavily regulated by the FCA. Eligible for FSCS protection up to £85,000.
Verdict: Stocks provide more consumer protection and regulatory clarity.
5. Ownership and Utility
Crypto: You can transfer, store, and use your crypto independently. It may have utility beyond trading.
Stocks: Ownership tied to financial returns and potential dividends, but little day-to-day utility.
Verdict: Crypto offers more direct control; stocks offer legal ownership of a business.
6. Tax Treatment in the UK
Crypto: Subject to Capital Gains Tax when sold. Rewards from staking or mining may be taxed as income.
Stocks: Also subject to Capital Gains Tax. Dividends taxed under dividend tax rules.
Bonus insight: HMRC doesn’t treat crypto as currency — it’s considered an asset. You must keep detailed records of all crypto transactions, including wallet-to-wallet transfers.
Pros and Cons of Crypto Trading
Pros:
Trade 24/7 with no geographic restrictions
Potential for very high short-term gains
Diversify away from traditional markets
Many platforms allow low-cost, instant trading
Cons:
Highly volatile and speculative
Regulatory uncertainty in the UK
Prone to scams and hacking risks
No investor protection from the FSCS
Pros and Cons of Stock Trading
Pros:
Regulated and safer for long-term investment
Opportunity for dividends and compound growth
Extensive historical data and analysis available
Eligible for ISA tax benefits (e.g. Stocks and Shares ISA)
Cons:
Restricted to weekday trading hours
Slower-moving compared to crypto
Can be affected by macroeconomic factors like inflation and interest rates
Which Is Better for Beginners?
For complete beginners, stock trading is usually a safer starting point. UK stocks are well regulated, less volatile, and offer educational opportunities through ISA schemes and pension investments.
Crypto, while exciting and accessible, requires more caution. New investors should treat it as a high-risk asset and only invest what they can afford to lose.
That said, many beginners dip into crypto using small, manageable amounts to learn the ropes.
Which Offers Better Returns?
Short-term: Crypto has the potential for rapid returns — and equally quick losses. Traders with a high risk appetite and good timing can profit substantially.
Long-term: Historically, stock markets have delivered steady growth over time, especially when reinvesting dividends and following a buy-and-hold approach.
The S&P 500, for example, has averaged 7–10% annual returns after inflation. While past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, stock markets remain a core wealth-building tool.
Overlooked angle: The best-performing investors often combine both, using stocks for stability and crypto for speculative growth.
Actionable Tips for UK Investors
Diversify across both markets. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket — split between crypto and stocks based on your risk tolerance.
Use tax-efficient wrappers. Use Stocks & Shares ISAs to avoid tax on stock profits. Crypto isn’t eligible, but you can manage exposure for better tax outcomes.
Avoid leverage unless you understand the risks. Especially in crypto, leverage can amplify losses fast.
Use FCA-registered platforms. Whether trading stocks or crypto, make sure your platform complies with UK regulations.
Set clear goals. Are you saving for retirement, or aiming for short-term profit? Your approach should match your objective.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is it better to invest in stocks or crypto?
It depends on your goals. Stocks are generally safer and better for long-term growth. Crypto may offer higher short-term returns but comes with greater risk and volatility.
Can I trade both crypto and stocks from the UK?
Yes. There are platforms that offer both (e.g. eToro), or you can use separate apps — one for stocks (like Freetrade or Hargreaves Lansdown), and one for crypto (like Binance or Kraken).
Is crypto regulated in the UK?
Crypto is regulated for anti-money laundering purposes, but not for consumer protection. Unlike stocks, crypto assets are not covered by the FSCS.
Are crypto gains taxed in the UK?
Yes. You may need to pay Capital Gains Tax on crypto profits above your annual allowance. Rewards from staking, mining, or airdrops may be treated as income.
Can I hold crypto in an ISA?
No. Currently, cryptocurrencies are not eligible for ISAs. Stocks and ETFs are. This gives stocks an edge in tax efficiency.
Final Thoughts
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether crypto trading or stock trading is better — both offer unique benefits and come with different levels of risk.
Choose crypto if you're comfortable with high volatility, want 24/7 access, and are seeking short-term speculative growth.
Choose stocks if you prefer long-term, regulated investing with the potential for dividend income and tax-efficient growth through ISAs.
Many smart UK investors incorporate both into their portfolios — stocks for security, and crypto for growth potential. The key is to understand what you’re investing in, stay informed, and never risk more than you can afford to lose.
Subscribe for more tips! Subscribe to our newsletter
Disclaimer: Smart With Money may receive compensation from affiliate links, advertisements, and partners featured on this site. This compensation does not influence our editorial content, reviews, or recommendations. Our opinions are our own, and we aim to provide accurate and objective financial information to help you make informed decisions.
Additionally, all content provided on SmartWithMoney.co.uk is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Please seek independent financial advice before making any financial decisions.